Open Classic Mafia 1 - Game over
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
vote: astolfo
Sorry typing from phone difficulties
Sorry typing from phone difficulties
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
Please use the following format when casting your vote:Votecount 2.3
Astolfo (1) Joolis, Eldrenia
Eldrenia (1) Astolfo
Not voting: Arkan, Auriona, Brocas, Isha
Astolfo is V/LA until Wednesday.
Deadline is February 3, 12 pm UTC+11 - deadline passed
With 7 alive, 4 votes are needed for a lynch.
Code: Select all
[b]Vote: Xoco[/b]
Last edited by xoco on Wed Feb 01, 2017 4:22 pm, edited 6 times in total.
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
I agree that lynching Eldrenia is the fastest way to find out the truth. Sorry Eldrenia
.
Vote: Eldrenia

Vote: Eldrenia
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
I see that Isha has shown their true colors, I will not even need to investigate them tonight!
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
Eldrenia is responsible for a mob killing an innocent and shows zero remorse. I have to say she looks guiltier and guiltier, with the only exception being Joolis, who appears to share that guilt. If not guilty, then she still brought this upon herself, though I would feel bad.
Vote: Lynch Eldrenia
Vote: Lynch Eldrenia
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
Joolis wrote:We've already lost 2 townspeople, there is no more time for games! Last night I investigated Astolfo and learned that he a vile member of the local Mafia! He and his cronies poach elephants for the ivory and they are trying to take over our town! We must save the elephants and lynch Astolfo!
Vote: Astolfo
So lets recap this. Joolis claims to be the sheriff and calls Astolfo out for being mafia. Astolfo makes a counter claim that I am the mafia and people jump on that band wagon because I tried to get someone talking who was being inactive. Let me tell you if you lynch me today the doctor better protect Joolis tonight because astolfo will have him killed.
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
VOTE ASTOLFO
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
Why you do dis to me?!
Ya'll are a lustful bunch for death and killing. Why can't we discuss things more without just jumping on bandwagons to lynch. Yes, we will learn something from today's lynching, but at what cost? Also, we still know so very little about Isha, Arkan, Auriona. I enjoyed observing the conversations between Joolis, Eldrenia and Astolfo today. That is what we need more of so we can figure out who the mafia is among us.
So based on my logic before, I think the less-risky play is lynching Eldrenia... at least then we won't accidentally kill a cop if Joolis is fooling us. I really don't like taking risks. The only way this would be a bad vote is if Eldrenia is the doctor. I suspect she isn't due to her post stating what the doc needs to do tonight if we are wrong and Eldrenia was good and Astolfo was lying. Normally we wouldn't want the doc to say who they are, as it makes them an instant target, but if you are the doc Eldrenia, I think now is time to share it given how this vote went.
I'm going to hold off on casting my vote. We still have 48 hours or more to make a decision. No reason to rush this and really screw things up. Those that voted already, is there anymore information that you want to share that lead you to this decision?
Ya'll are a lustful bunch for death and killing. Why can't we discuss things more without just jumping on bandwagons to lynch. Yes, we will learn something from today's lynching, but at what cost? Also, we still know so very little about Isha, Arkan, Auriona. I enjoyed observing the conversations between Joolis, Eldrenia and Astolfo today. That is what we need more of so we can figure out who the mafia is among us.
So based on my logic before, I think the less-risky play is lynching Eldrenia... at least then we won't accidentally kill a cop if Joolis is fooling us. I really don't like taking risks. The only way this would be a bad vote is if Eldrenia is the doctor. I suspect she isn't due to her post stating what the doc needs to do tonight if we are wrong and Eldrenia was good and Astolfo was lying. Normally we wouldn't want the doc to say who they are, as it makes them an instant target, but if you are the doc Eldrenia, I think now is time to share it given how this vote went.
I'm going to hold off on casting my vote. We still have 48 hours or more to make a decision. No reason to rush this and really screw things up. Those that voted already, is there anymore information that you want to share that lead you to this decision?
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
If you kill Eldrenia there won't be any more risks to take because the game will more or less be over and it won't matter who the cop was. I have put forth my claims, which were not refuted, and others have voted for Eldrenia because they "feel" she is guilty. I am fairly certain she is not the doctor, but rather is making the suggestion to protect me in anticipation of her own death.
Re: Open Classic Mafia 1 - Day 2
I don't think people are voting for Eldrenia necessarily because she's guilty. But when you have two people claiming to be the cop and you have no idea which one is telling the truth, what do you do? Kill one of them and hope you're not killing the real cop? Lynching Eldrenia will tell us for SURE which of you is the real cop. If Astolfo is lying, we can lynch him tomorrow. If you're lying, we can lynch you tomorrow. Either way, tomorrow we'll be able to lynch a definite member of the mafia.
If you're telling the truth, you have nothing to worry about. It sucks that Eldrenia could possibly be a town sacrifice, but we don't know that. She could also be mafia. If she is, then you're right, maybe the game will be over tomorrow =).
If you're telling the truth, you have nothing to worry about. It sucks that Eldrenia could possibly be a town sacrifice, but we don't know that. She could also be mafia. If she is, then you're right, maybe the game will be over tomorrow =).