Open Classic Mafia 1 - Game over

[Astolfo]

I chose more or less at random....!

The matter of elphants being poached, let alone the more important issue of people in our town being killed, begs far more care then claims of complancey "chose(n) more or less at random" that you put forward Joolis. I offer the people of the town the logic of my investigative choice in stark contrast to your 'randomness'. I looked at the person who started the lynch of a innocent town member, Eldrenia. I found that person, Eldrenia, is the mafia goon, who has the ability to kill a town member at night. Which Eldrenia used to kill Bubba just this last evening. You are going to far out of the way to defend Eldrenia. Your 'Random' claims are not enough at this point, in our context. I've offered something more. A rationale basis for my activity. You have neither a rationale basis nor truth behind you Joolis. That is why the citizens of our town will vote to lynch Eldrenia today, and you tomorrow.

[Astolfo]

OOC FYI I'm out for work for till at least Wednesday. I'll try and be back to address whatever happens after that.
Cheers!

[Joolis]

No one gave any clear signs the first day, simply starting a lynch does not make someone a Mafia member. I had to choose someone and I caught you red handed!

[Joolis]

I find it laughable that you claim to be the cop and to have found the goon on the very first night! How convenient for you to come forth with this information only after being slated for death. If I end up dying to you and your goons before tomorrow, at least I know I have saved at least one poor elephant from harm this day!

[Brocas]

We have 2 people claiming to be cops trying to justify who they want to lynch today. The way I see, if we lynch Eldreina and we are wrong, then we know Astolfo is mafia poacher and lynch him tomorrow. If we lynch Astolfo today and we are wrong, then we know Joolis is mafia poacher and we lynch him tomorrow. In the 2nd scenario, we lose a cop in the process of uncovering the true mafia.

My personal opinion on what I've read so far, I agree with Joolis that Elderina wasn't TRYING to get someone killed. I would have liked to see no one lynched yesterday and starting the lynch did get some people talking. It's really a shame that Carlia didn't speak at all those 4 days. I currently am leaning towards Astolfo being mafia, but I am afraid to lynch him and lose our cop if Joolis is playing us all.

[Joolis]

Astolfo has not refuted the fact that I saw him aiding and abetting elephant poachers, instead he creates some elaborate logic that couldn't possibly be true since no one knew anything on the first day. If you abstain from voting, the town will surely be lost after only 2 days!

[Brocas]

Joolis, please know that I am not abstaining from voting, I just want to hear more discussions first. Please don't try rush me into a rash decision.

PS, I really don't think we are supposed to be RPing here. I think this is just a standard mafia game. Mafia aren't poachers, townies aren't elephants, etc... MOD: Can you confirm if we should be RPing here or not?

[xoco]

Votecount 2.2


Astolfo (1) Joolis
Eldrenia (1) Astolfo

Not voting: Arkan, Auriona, Brocas, Eldrenia, Isha

Astolfo is V/LA until Wednesday.

Deadline is February 3, 12 pm UTC+11 - 3 day, 3 hours, 0 minutes

With 7 alive, 4 votes are needed for a lynch.

The game is OOC. I suggest people keep it that way so that everyone can focus on the argumentation rather than the flavor/RP, but I'm not about to police it. Do what makes you happy.

So that there can be no confusion about whether someone is calling other players to lynch a player or informing mod of their vote, please use the following format when casting your vote:

Code: Select all

[b]Vote: Xoco[/b]
OR
[b]VOTE: Xoco[/b]

[/color][/b]

viewtopic.php?f=74&t=3794#p27729

[Eldrenia]

I'm going with the cop.

vote: astrolo

[Eldrenia]

vote: astolfo

Sorry typing from phone difficulties