Open Classic Mafia 1 - Game over

[Isha]

It really sucks that the entire game hinges on my vote. I'm terrified of casting the wrong vote . I wish Arkan would say something.

[Brocas]

There is no rush Isha. We have 4 days until the deadline. I'll gladly discuss anything you wish to talk about. I am certainly not jealous of the position you are in. I hate the pressure!

[xoco]

Votecount 4.1


Arkan (1) Brocas

Not voting: Arkan, Isha

Deadline is February 11, 12 pm UTC+11 - 3 days, 3 hours, 24 minutes

With 3 alive, 2 votes are needed for a lynch.

Please use the following format when casting your vote:

Code: Select all

[b]Vote: Xoco[/b]

If you haven't read the first page by now, it would be a good idea to do so. All the answers to your confusions are there. This is an open setup and all roles were revealed before the game began.[/color][/b]
viewtopic.php?p=27730#p27730

[Arkan]

Obviously I am not claiming to be the doctor, because I need Isha to vote not to lynch me and she is clearly the doctor. The mafia head probably received the goon powers when the goon died. Or your theory is right, Isha. Either way, Brocas's voting behavior has always been to lynch someone. If I was mafia, wouldn't I always want to lynch to push my agenda of killing all non-mafia? Vote to lynch Brocas and the village may be saved, though a much sadder place than before.

Vote: Lynch Brocas the Mafia

[Isha]

Well, we have four days, but I guess I don't really see the need to draw it out. I've suspected Brocas for a few days now, and while his explanations make sense, they're a little to slimy and leading for my taste. I really hope I'm making the right choice here....

Vote: Brocas

[Brocas]

Isha, you are making a grave mistake. Can you please let me know what parts seem slimy to you? Arkan lurked most of this game, hiding in the shadows. Nothing of what he just said implicates me. Of course he's not gonna claim doc or vote himself. He voted just as much as me except the day he was inactive. Town loses if you kill me!

[Isha]

It really is a 50/50 coin toss here. It sucks, but I can't know one way or the other. In the end, I have to rely on my instincts and you've just been working so hard to "help out" and guide me to the answers. It's almost a case of "protesting to much." You know what I mean? It's like you were spelling it all out for me so I'd pick Arkan, but I never really felt like it was coming from a place of "I'm a townie, you have to believe me."

So it came across to me like you were trying to frame Arkan. And then when Arkan speaks, he's uncertain, he doesn't really know what's going on, he's not really clear on how the mafia works. So it makes me feel like you know a little too much, even though I understand that all the information is available on the front page.

I hope that makes sense? In the end, it comes down to the fact that I mistrusted you early on and through our conversations today, I've had a hard time dismissing my misgivings. So....we'll see what happens. I hope I'm not wrong, but if I am, I'm sorry =(.

[xoco]

Vote: Lynch Brocas the Mafia

Not counting this. Please format it correctly if you intend it to be a real vote.

[Arkan]

Vote: Brocas

[Brocas]

Isha, I think you are interpreting my logic incorrectly... making it seem like i'm trying to frame Arkan. I'm not. I was just trying to logically explain my decision and thought process so you wouldn't think I was trying to frame him. It's a shame that it came cross too strongly and making you misinterpret me. Please go back and reread the thread. I had the best intentions of the town in mind the entire time.

With regard to our experience, please don't think that just because Arkan doesn't seem to know what's going on, that he's not mafia. He could be dumb playing in an attempt to look innocent. Yes, this is not my first rodeo. I have played mafia games before which is why it seems like I'm being pushy or know too much. Again, just because I've played before and I read the rules and game setup a few times, doesn't mean that I'm mafia.

Please, just reexamine this thread and you'll see that I am not the mafia here.